VIPLSATCracking LSAT makes you a VIP.

Logical Reasoning · Point at Issue (Agreement)

PrepTest 127 · Section 2 · Question 2

Phase 1 (your first ~400 questions): read the guidance, then answer. No clock.

Step 1 · Pre-Question Guidance · read this first

Question type
Point at Issue (Agreement)
The one idea it tests
Two speakers who argue about the best fix can still share a hidden belief that both fixes need.
The basic logic
Use the Two-Clipboard Test in reverse: the right answer gets a check mark on BOTH clipboards. Look for the secret sauce each plan relies on. If both plans only work when people make a choice, both speakers believe people can choose.
Tiny words that decide it
  • “only when”
  • “No”
  • “most”
  • “agree”

Playground logic

Frankie wants a sure, big penalty for litter; Sharon wants fun bins that make tidying appealing. Their patties differ, but both burgers share one secret sauce: kids decide whether to leave trash behind. A penalty can't scare someone who has no choice, and a fun bin can't tempt them either.

Step 2 · The kid story

The Great Lunchroom Litter Debate

The lunchroom floor looks like a tornado ate a sandwich. Frankie stands on a chair. "Litter will stop only when every litterbug surely loses dessert, and the loss is big enough that nobody thinks it's worth it!" Sharon stands on the next chair. "Wrong! Put out fun bins, the kind that play a song when you toss trash in. Kids who thought dropping wrappers was the only fast way to get to recess will pick the bin instead." They glare at each other. Ms. Rivera tells them both to get off the chairs. Priya writes on a napkin: "Frankie: scare them into choosing right. Sharon: tempt them into choosing right." Lulu reads it and smiles. "So you two do agree on something. You both think kids choose whether to drop trash." Frankie and Sharon say "Hmph" together.

Step 3 · Try the model question

Frankie: Litter will stop only when every litterbug is sure to lose dessert, and the loss is big enough to change their mind. Sharon: No, the best fix is fun bins, so that kids who saw dropping wrappers as the quickest way to recess will decide to use the bins instead.

The conversation best supports the idea that Frankie and Sharon share which belief?

Choices

Step 4 · The courtroom tale

Two Lawyers, One Belief

In the fictional Town of Puddleton, two lawyers argued about late library books. Ms. Kettle said, "Books will come back on time only when the fine is certain and steep." Mr. Whitfield tugged his suspenders. "No, Your Honor. Send friendly reminder postcards with a joke on them, and readers will decide to return books." The judge listened, then smiled. "Counselors, you disagree on the fix. But you both assume readers can choose to return a book or keep it. A fine only works on someone who can choose. So does a joke." Both lawyers opened their mouths to object, found nothing to object to, and closed them again.

Step 5 · Work the real question

Open PrepTest 127, Section 2, Question 2 in your official copy from LSAC (for example in LawHub) and read it there.

Your answer

How to apply it

Notice the stem asks what the two speakers agree on, not what they fight about. Write down each speaker's plan in a few words. Then ask what each plan needs to be true in order to work at all. Look for a belief hiding under both plans. Check each choice against both clipboards: if only one speaker would sign it, it is out. If neither speaker addressed it, it is out. Keep the choice both would sign.